How do you start a new game without getting rid another game you have started with a different toon. I am wanting to start a new game with a different race/class combo but when I click on new it just brings up my saved games. I dont see anything in there where I can actually start a new game from scratch and still have my other games saved.

Save your game and quit and click new game and don't save over the other chacter

I have saved the game and quit out when I load the game back up and click on new it pops a box out to the side with the saved games from where I started on a different toon. Unless I am misunderstanding what you are saying if so my apologies.

your loading the game back up all you did was save-quit-load on the main meun there should be contuine new load or quit click new and it should start a new game

DrHojo is correct. You have to save, then quit, then go to the main menu can select new game.