-Has a high fantasy art style
- Should have a realistic art style. By realistic i don't mean that it should look like the lord of the rings. I mean that everything should appear at least somewhat feasible or magic. Examples
--- Pale purple grass (fine)
--- strange dunmer architecture and metal dwemer ruins (fine)
--- daedra made of fire (fine)
--- Odd buildings (fine)
--- mushroom trees (somewhat fine)
--- Big weapons (no)
--- Any of the stupid armours or clothes seen so far (all of them) (No)

What it plays as- third person. likely mmo controls
what it should be- First person (with possible third person option)

what we have: appears to be strict classes and races and levels.
what we should have- A bunch of skills. In the beginning we set attributes and starting stats and a birthsign and a race.

What we have :Silly world war with three races on each side with different specialities (mage, warrior and "rogue" ) Only now redguards are probably theives. Bosmer or khajit might be warriors and the dumner get along with nords and argonians?
What we should have: anything else. It probably isn't so stupid.