You've probably tried newer gfx drivers, etc. Okay, so this COULD work with fraps, but you'll expire your harddrive with recording.
Download Dxtory(or Bandicam, but I haven't used it), wait the ten second startup time(free trial delay, that's it) and in the Advanced section, check the box with "Limit FPS" like so:
http://i.minus.com/ibyOmv0tgLFwPT.png
That's all you need. You can disable any overlays in the other tabs. F11/F12 snapshot and record, but you won't be needing those.
EDIT: Limit the FPS to 100-120. You get a scrolling scanline of sorts if it's at 60.
I might try 59 FPS later but 100 works fine for me.

