I predict I might get ~$50 for these trade-ins (I'll also be taking in an old broken controller) and I want to get a game that will keep my entertained at least until the next big Steam sale (the christmas one I think). I was thinking Skyrim because even though I got terribly bored of it after one playthrough on my 360, I've been browsing the mods and they seem like they add an INSANE amount of content.
I don't know, what do you guys think?