To this day, it bugs me that Oblivion's GOTY edition didn't come with all the extra content. My hope is that for Skyrim, they do what they've done with the last two Fallout games: have GOTY editions that include all the post-launch material. A "Game of the Year" edition should be a total experience package.

Just wait. After the second add-on (probably "Hearthfire") comes out, they'll release the base game plus both add-ons. They did the same with Oblivion and Morrowind. But right now, it's too soon.

Doesn't matter to me. By that time, I'll have all the stuff anyway.

That's exactly the problem. Skyrim will have more than two DLC, so releasing GOTY with only Dawnguard and Hearthfire means people will have to wait for yet another edition, this time Ultimate. It's confusing. Bethesda should wait until all the DLC are out and then release GOTY.

Yep, and that's my problem. I bought Oblivion GOTY for my PS3 only to discover there was DLC that wasn't on the disc and, as all PS3 purchasers discovered, no plans to bring that content over. That's why Bethesda should wait until they're *done* and then release an all-encompassing package (expansions, minor DLC, etc.). Like with FO3 and NV, I don't mind getting another copy of the game that has everything together on-disc. Otherwise, I feel screwed/nickel and dimed.