Using an ESM nowadays isn't required as a solution to certain bugs/problems. Most of those issue's have been resolved. Unless you are adding HUGE worldspace an ESM shouldn't be necessary.
There is a trick to copying into new plugins. I vaguely remember reading something of the procedure.
Make a new empty plugin and load it as the active plugin alongside your old one. Simply make duplicates of all the cells you wish to keep, save the plugin. Close the CK and remove your old plugin from Skyrim/Data.
I could be wrong, as I think there is more to it than that, make sure to backup your old plugin.