I made this thread mainly just to ask this question: Is the Halflings leaf meant to be a narcotic? I ask this because of a few statements in the books, for example Saruman says to Gandalf: "Too much of the halfling's leaf has addled your mind", tobacco does not addle one's mind as far as I know. Also add to this Saruman's large supply of it at Orthanc and implied addiction (not sure if the addiction was implied, or if that's just me misremembering.)