» Wed May 16, 2012 11:40 pm
While you're at it, single-shot crossbows were only a European thing. The Chinese have had repeating crossbows since before their Immortals putatively met the Spartans in the service of Xerxes and, until the deveolpment of the rifled barrel, the repeating crossbow was the most advanced single-operator weapon on the battlefield. After the Greeks tried and failed to reverse engineer the weapon of the Immortals, the Romans developed the Scorpius. This was a slow loading single-shot weapon requiring at least two operators, but a single bolt shot from a Scorpius could perforate the shields of several men standing in line (as well as perforating the men as well) and may have led to the perception that Roman soldiers needed to learn to fight in more dispersed formations (i.e. loose formations favouring the Spatha over the Gladius; being less vulnerable to weapons like the Scorpius).
.
The repeating cross-bow is an assault weapon and, if memory serves, it was only ever outperformed by breech-loading rifles. If the Nords get crossbows, the Altmer (& by extension, the Thalmer) should get repeating crossbows (with gravity-fed cartidge on the top of the weapon), and the Imperials should get the Scorpius (instant death if hit by a Scorpius bolt and only operable with the assistance of your in-game companion NPC). Regular crossbows would take at least twice as long to reload and aim as a bow, while the repeating crossbow can be reloaded in half to three-quarters of the time to redraw a bow without necessarily losing aim. This rate of fire for a repeating crossbow would only apply to a journeyman-expert level bowman. By comparison, breechloading rifles generally take much longer to reload, but due to their much higher effective range they gain superiority over repeating cross-bows. It is important to remember that limitations on rate of fire, range, and accuracy are all favoured or disadvantaged by different conditions and that it is the correct selection of technology with respect to the nature of the ground which determines its effectiveness.
.
One more thing. Longbows are argued by some to be the most powerful single-shot weapon of the period. An arrow from a longbow could perforate carbon steel plate armour and had a tremendous range if the archer understood the ballistics. Longbowmen had to be trained from childhood and so I think that a correction is due here. Longbows should be the most powerful single-operator ranged weapon in the game - but should also require master or, at least, expert level archery skill to use. The longbow is also almost as tall as the archer that wields it, so if the correction is made by somoeone the former "longbows" in the game need to be renamed "shortbows" and the longbow placed with a mesh of its own. The design is very simple but, in its time and place, the longbow was very much the cutting edge of military technology.
.
Anyway, just some thoughts...