It seems the only way to justify keeping the companions around is if I intentionally gimp my character and play with abstract house rules. I know the simple answer is "Don't recruit any of them". I tried but I like having them around for flavor. From what I remember "recruits" in either Oblivion or FO3 (except Fawkes) were't this crazy.
I'm on the pc so if there are any mods I missed that dropped their superstar status to supporting role or if it's easily done through the geck myself please let me know. I guess what I want is all companions to be similar to ED-E's effectivness (or ineffectivness, however you see it), at least he lets me play too
