Because the ones that are being sold/shared before official release date are pirate copies. Fine is propably for sharing the copy.
The person said not to buy it early. So I think he bought it and got caught
Who would actually hand out the fine?
Not all copies sold/played early are pirated copies
Here http://www.geeksailor.com/modern-warfare-3-torrent-piracy-activision-fine/
I wouldn't give em back the disk, unless they paid me for it.
I wanna know what the fine was for, because I wouldn't siggtake that fine for no reason