So, originally, I had started up an engagement with Ysolda but left her at the alter and didn't go through with it. Every time I ran into her after that I got the "I can't believe you're still speaking to me after what you've done" line and had the option to "start over" with her.

Well, after that, I ended up marrying Muiri and moved her in.

I walk past Ysolda at some point later and she gives me that same line about breaking her heart... I notice the speech option "can't we just start over?" and thought what the hell. Sure enough, she says ok and tells me to talk to the priest to arrange our wedding. (don't tell muiri.)

Went back to the priest and the little quest arrow is pointing at him but he wont give me the "arrange marriage" option.... probably because he remembers marrying me to muiri just a few days prior. So I have another unfinishable quest entry in my journal to get married. Obviously I shouldnt have been able to get engaged again. But I did.

Well, here's what i'm wondering.... what if I had proposed to muiri and then went to ysolda and got my second wedding chance BEFORE I went to the priest.... would they both have shown up? hmm... Perhaps someone who isnt married yet would want to give this a whirl.

This only works in Utah. ::sarcasm::

Well, that and Whiterun apparently.

Hmmm. Maybe Whiterun IS in Utah.... ROFL!! Oh man, THAT would be a kick and a half!