I drop him to his knees, and then try to decide what to do about it. I decide to loot the camp while I think about the implications of an NPC Imperial that can't be killed after the rebellion quest is complete. I don't want this guy to keep coming after me while I loot, so (here comes the good part), I tell Mjoll to "wait here" right next to the guy, and walk off a ways to watch. He stands up, pulls his sword and Mjoll drops him to his knees in one hit. So I looted the camp while Mjoll watched our immortal prisoner, dropped him to his knees one last time, and ran off.....
I imagine this would work with any immortal NPC as long as your companion can put them down with one or two hits, or uses ranged attacks.
I'll add a question, about the immortal Imperial. Can I go back and re-win Skyrim for the Imperials? What kind of quest related nonsense keeps me from being able to kill this guy?
