And apparently
stopped reading rather than knowing, fully, what you were talking about.
Over the power level of companions. You're feeling the impulse to walk away from a game like Skyrim because a minor, non-essential part of the game isn't to your specific liking. Like I said, I'd like Destruction magic to be more to my liking... but it isn't. So I choose to not be petulant about it and keep playing because I know that Bethesda isn't creating the game specifically for me and my appetites. You might want to give that a try.
This is really devoted fan logic, and I reject it.
World of Warcraft, a MMORPG, follows this rule: it has to work (more or less) for everyone -- it is a multiplayer game, after all, and everyone agrees to play by the same rules. I don't like all their decisions, hate a great number, but (such as it is) its the best they can do for "everyone". And that's fine.
You may not have noticed but you can actually add in modifications to games like Skyrim, Oblivion, etc. These bits of code and graphics let you
intentionally alter how the game works in many small ways, large ways, and fundamental ways. The game even has a difficulty slider for people who want little challenge or to be beaten senseless by sand fleas. Skyrim, Oblivion, and games like them are not about "playing Bethy's way" but, given the intentionally built-in modding resources, it is about playing the game
my way. To recycle your admonishment:
you might want to give that a try.
That is the beauty of single-player games: you don't have to compromise to find something that works for everyone.
Unlike World of Warcraft, if I want to be over-powered, under-powered, or differently powered, alter the environment, meshes, point of the game, etc...I can, and it's cool. You don't like how Destruction is or its focus on dual-casting, there's a mod for that. Don't like the relative power of dragon armor vs dadric, there's a mod for that. Don't like how easy/hard/annoying something is, there might be a mod for that.
If this companion business
were an intentional design issue, and it was articulated by Bethy, and you were notified in-game that companions will only go along with you for so long then want to 'retire' then fine. If not happy with that, mod file. However, that isn't the case and it really does appear to be a bug they got lazy with and ignored (like many others). That's no way to earn the trust or confidence of the user.
With Oblivion, I played when it first came out and put it on the shelf after a month of trying to get through it: too many bugs, too many poor design decisions, too much headache. I let it gather dust on the shelf for a few years (while official and unofficial patches were finished) then reinstalled it, and I'm
much happier for it. The unofficial patches fixes the last of the really batty bugs, there were mods for many tweaks, entire cities were designed
far better than Bethy had considered, cities could be populated with enough people to
feel like a city, yadda, yadda. I've enjoyed Oblivion as a fantastic world away from WoW and have been playing it steadily until Skyrim came out. "
You might want to give that a try" or maybe not: its a single-player game, you go find your own way to enjoy it.
Personally, I do not want to play an open-world game where I'm afraid to go into a tavern as I may lock-low a companion I might want to use later, leaving quests un-delivered on the off chance. I don't find that fun; others may not care and goody for them. I can't help it if that bothers you, but honestly who are you to be bothered by it in the first place? I'm not telling
you how to play, why do you entertain the idea that you have the right to tell me how to play? If I choose to toss Skyrim on the shelf till the bugs are worked out and the game-tailoring mods I want are available, that's not petulance, that's my call. I get to decide on what is/isn't "fun" and I certainly hope you find it within yourself one day to recognize both that frustration != petulance and that a there are times when you simply
don't settle for telling yourself that something for amusemant and fun when it is neither amusing nor fun.
Enjoy the thread, I'll leave it to you.