» Mon Jun 04, 2012 6:32 am
The family members are by default essential and remain so if you choose not to destroy them. By choosing not to kill Astrid in your first meeting, you've told the game that you might join the Brotherhood, and so it's waiitng for you to progress.
If you were to kill Astrid, shrouded armor can be taken from her body, and shrouded robes can be found on Festus Krex, Gabriella, and sitting on a shelf by the entrance.
If the guards are after you, you have a bounty from somewhere, or are a vampire. They don't automatically become agreesive for joining the Brotherhood, and you receive no bounty for killing any of Astrid's hostages.