Video here: http://www.gametrailers.com/video/best-role-playing-game-of-the/725239

Do you guys think this ruling was fair?

yes. A game that appeals to all ages and give you 300+ hours of gameplay plus a lot of action for the action lovers. Yes I dont even play RPG's but then I took an arrow to the knee. I havent played it yet cuz some ebay seller doesnt want to ship the game out until two days after I pay for it.

At least it won game of the year right?

No, Dragon Age 2 shouldn't be on that list.

On a serious note: That's like, their opinion man. It doesn't affect you and if they thought it was better good for them, personally I haven't played Dark Souls so I can't attest for whether or not it was that good but it doesn't really matter whether or not Skyrim lost. Do you enjoy it? Whatever the answer, alright then.