» Sun Jun 10, 2012 12:26 am
Obviously you can have a spear be in the game. There are legitimate questions about how useful a spear would be for a one-on-one fight, if you had any concern at all about them having any relation at all to how spears actually work.
I saw it in the video, and I have no objection to it being in the game - but what I do find silly is this sort of combined spear/bo staff. A real, lethal spear is long and heavy. You can't swing it around speedily like a bo staff to hit somebody in the head and daze them. And anything as light and quick as a bo staff, you can't just stick a pointy end on it and make it a lethal spear. Real hand-to-hand melee spears were like what hoplites in ancient Greece carried - long and heavy and thick. Throwing spears like the pila the Romans carried were a little shorter and lighter, but still had to carry enough weight to penetrate shields.
So basically, go ahead an put spears in the game, but not this combined spear/bo staff business. I never have understood the lust for spears that some people seem to burn with, but by all means, create a reasonable spear mechanic and add them in.