» Wed Jun 13, 2012 7:20 am
It seems to only work with particular NPCs. Killing the old owner of the Alchemist's shop in Markarth results in her young apprentice taking over ownership of the store.
This isn't true for a lot, if not most merchant NPCs though. At least in my experience.
On one of my evil characters I'd just finished training my alchemy as high as it could go with Arcadia. Being evil I opted to not pickpocket my gold back this time and instead murder-kill-deathed her to get my money back. After merrily skipping out of town with the blood of an innocent shopkeeper on my hands, I returned to Whiterun after some time away to find that she hadn't been replaced and her corpse was still on the floor of her shop. Being all corpsey, y'know doing corpse stuff, the things that corpses do. She was still all the different kinds of dead except for the 'un' kind is what I'm trying to say.
Whether or not I didn't stay out of it long enough for a reset to occur or Arcadia simply doesn't have anyone to take over her shop, the result was the same. I was minus one Alchemy shopkeeper with no replacement in sight. I get the feeling the same is true for most shopkeepers in Skyrim, some will get replaced but probably only those with people you can meet to take over.