So, I'm doing something with Lucil that is slightly out of character, however, it is necessary. In a certain quest I need to go through the College of Winterhold for some info. But I also don't want people to acknowledge Lucil as being in the mages guild because he is not. So I'm trying to get kicked out now that I have the info I need, so far though:

-I stole in front of a lady, but they really haven't kicked me out. Worse of the lady attacks me, my follower at current tried killing her and she won't die

-That's another thing, it appears that like every mage in here doesn't die. So I can't murder them to get out of the college either

All for the sake of not being acknowledged in the mages guild. Cause I'll start getting comments about being the newest member of Winterhold. And no.

If this needed info pertains to the MQ, bypass the College of Winterhold and head north. RP that you're trying to find the backdoor in and in the process, happen to notice a cave out there...

So, reload before me getting into the college? Cause trying to kill these people isn't working. I've been trying to get kicked out of the college for a while now. Not really working.

What Sojourner says is the best option. Another is to get in a magic duel with another mage and fight with weapons and not magic. This does require level 50 in any school of magic, though.

You could try killing that high elf that's always whining about Faralda.