Holy mother of [censored]. Did you try doing something else not related to ammo?
Well, I did make a bunch of steaks (gecko, brahmin, etc.). But at the time of that screenshot, I was just sitting around making ammo and crap, thinking I can unlock it. In the GAME itself, I have the challenges already.
I don't think my problem is opening the console, since I never opened it. The problem is that I'm getting all the OTHER achievements except the crafty. I just finished getting all the quest achievements.