i got the game with 3 disc and thought o cool a long game to play (ya i get that it uses three bc its a really good graphic game) but really i beat the game in a day and i did all the side quest and searched everywhere for everything......

If you didn't get completionist achievement you didn't "finish" the game.

Either way the game was really short. It should have been longer and less linear. From Bethesda I was counting on a game as engrossing as one of the Elder Scrolls games, or Fallout games. This wasn't up to the bar they set with those games.

How many hours did it take you? I believe i'm pretty close to the end, and i'm 10ish hours deep.

It took me 21 hours but I did all the side quests, roamed around an played the games. The game was great but I felt empty with the ending lol.

this is not a RPG but a FPS.
6 years in the making and it is a ID game before bethesda bought them out.
so any issues would be on ID no so much on bethesda. just like Fallout New Vegas was on the F3 engine but Obsidian did the programing, thank god Skyrim is Bethesda studios game.