I was also skeptical because of the reviews it got.
Could you perhaps elaborate a bit on the pros and cons?
Sure.
Pros.
Excellent Story, on par with Martin (Since he supervised everything)
Great Graphics
Many options for different play styles
Both of the characters play and feel differently
Branching paths and plenty of dialogue options and very grey choices
Cons.
The face models are...re-used alot in common NPCS
The voice acting is one of the most hit and miss things i have ever seen...Mors is AMAZING, I LOVE HIS gruff voice...while others....*Shudders*
Combat is...MEH...but its made up with all the options you have.