Games that svck don't get overwhelmingly positive reviews.
A.) Not true.
B.) Who said Skyrim svcks? I haven't even played it yet. But there are still sure signs that they've lost their touch, and just like Blizzard has in recent years been known for its new cartoony art/animation style, Bethesda is starting to become known for a big open world completely devoid of intelligent life... and also bad animations (which seem to be mostly corrected in this game, thank god). The bucket thing could be pretty hilarious, and I'm all for having optional aspects of the game being that it's single player only (see: Spell Creation, mounted combat, all the lost weapon types, all the lost spell types, etc, etc... mostly things Bethesda takes out little by little, game after game, for absolutely no reason), my complaint was more aimed at the NPCs complete lack of reaction when the bucket's removed and his companion is laying in a bloody mess obviously within sight (I definitely got a good laugh from whoever said it's good to see that the AI line of sight is working).