urgh all this talk of batman. i tell you all its one of the worst games ive ever played. no block button, hammer one button to attack, a indicator appears on screen telling you to counter attack, grappling hook is auto aim, jumping is mostly automated, attacking from above is automated.... its hardly a game. the only thing you do yourself is those silly riddler puzzles and the remote controlled batarang. cant stand it. its near impossible to even die. its not fair it sells well simply because its batman. at least they added upgrades this time around.

when will the day come that FP/RPG/IS genre is widely recognised as the greatest. i dont even see it as a opinion, i see it as a fact.
apologies about that rant. im not usually bitter like that but it just makes me mad, and with good reason.
to make up for that off-topic rant here is my "merciful melee mechanic" contribution, taken from another post of mine.
you have to "aim" your shield whilst blocking, is the enemy thrusting? just hold block. is the enemy striking from above? whilst holding block you have to hold up aswell to hold the shield up. is the enemy slashing? hold block and left or right depending on which direction hes slashing from. the only drawback to this is either movement or looking would not be possible whilst blocking (at least on consoles) i believe movement would be the best sacrifice, since your blocking you wont be doing much moving anyway. just let go of block and you can run dodge etc again. imo this would make combat very engaging and challenging, and revolutionise first person melee, especially if magika and ammunition was limited so melee is essential at times(if your not playing stealth only that is).
this would definately need more thought though. but its a great concept.