» Sat Nov 17, 2012 1:59 pm
i gave 3 reaper gems to the alter on my last playthrough and got nothing, however, i had two in my inventory at the same time, only one showed up in the light, maybe you need to only have one at a time in your inv. when turning them in? im sure that was the problem, when i placed the third gem into the altar, i got to meet with reaper who gave me three black soul gem instead of reaper shards!