» Tue Jun 12, 2012 3:16 am
Scimitars are one of the most effective as a lower ranking sword (along with skyforge weapons) but towards the higher level they become less effective which makes sense for the reason that the Redguards are not renown for their ability in smithing and producing metals such as steel. My guess is that the sword is good due to its design and shape rather than due to expert knowledge of smithing. The design could even be one brought across from Yokuda.
According to lore, Nords are best at making steel and orcs are best at smithing. We don't see it in Skyrim for some strange reason, but I believe chainmail is supposed to be a Nord speciality). Then Imperials are the probably most effective at enterprising weapon manufacturing (steel plate & ebony?).
I have a Redguard character who wears either Redguard clothes or dresses in full dwarven armor (as fitting in with Hammerfell lore). This character still uses scimitars as choice of main weapon (plus dwarven shield, dwarven bow & dwarven axe)