So I had a level 18 character but since the main storyline quest I'm on was bugged and I couldn't progress any farther I started a new character until Bethesda decides to fix it. I looked it up online and people were saying that 2 characters at once is possible, as long as you manually save the new character. So after I did my first manual save my old level 18 character was gone...what is the logic in that? Can anyone tell me how to fix this if there is anyway to get my old character back? Or how you can manage to play 2 characters at the same time on a single gamer profile? Bethesda is really screwing up on this game, its fun and all just stupid stuff like this and the main story quests really grind my gears, at least I have AC Revelations to play....
Not tying to sound like a d*ck, but that's your fault, not Bethesda's. You must of accidentally saved over your other character some how, it happened to me while playing oblivion, I made a new character, and accidentally saved over my level 20 Battlemage, right after finishing the Shivering Isles quest, I know how you feel, I was extremely pissed.