Well my beef is that Alteration and the clunky hotkey system makes it quite cumbersome to keep up (especially with the constant need of recasts..) Armor gives same upside and no recast, just wear and forget, or am I missing something.
Armor has weight. The alteration spells don't.
Plus improving your alteration skill will improve all the spells in the school. Whereas armor skill only governs the use of armor.
Though alteration requires magicka and recasts but armor doesn't require casting, as you have mentioned.
Both have their pros and cons.