You usually need only 2 ingredients. But sometimes by adding another one gives you a different potion.
What you must do is:
Click on INGREDIENTS (top of the left list). If you have an ingredient with only 2 effects revealed (like Beehive Husk - resist poison / fort. light armor) click on the ingredient then choose one in the left list (in that case try Fortify Sneak) and you'll get some ingredients like Frost Mirriam, Hawk Feathers, Purple Mountain Flower. Click on one of these ingredients. Like Frost Mirriam. You'll have "Potion of unknown effect". So make this potion and it says: Discovered effects: Fortify Sneak (Beehive Husk). Now your Beehive Husk has 3 revealed effects and you have increased your alchemy. And so on... You can also improve your skill by creating expensive potions. All kind of poisons like damage health, stamina etc. are more expensive and increase your alchemy.
Now, by adding Hawk Feathers to Beehive Husk and Frost Mirriam (Potion of Fortify Sneak) you get another effect like Increase Light Armor. So now you have a potion with 2 effects. If you add instead Purple Mountain Flower you get a second effect with Resist Frost Damage. These potions will be more expensive and you'll increase your skill. Try.... Try....
