I found myself surprised at how different the game can look just using the right cables for console. I started playing on PS3 with component cables and found myself thinking I could sort of understand why people were on the game for blurry effects and whatever. Save corrupted. I needed to redownload. Switched over to 360, plugged in via HDMI. Difference was night and day. The lighting effects seemed to improve, objects looked more defined, colors sharper. So I'm wondering if it's a matter of the TV used and cables as well because the whole comparing Dishonored to [insert game over 5 years old], without qualification, doesn't make sense anymore for me.
Now I understand. I've just grown so used to the presence of my HDMI cables connecting my PS3 to my HD 56" Sharp Aquos LCD that I didn't think of this as a factor, and have been reading all this stuff everywhere about how atrocious the console versions look compared to PC and was nonplussed. My version looks great - I feel sorry for people who don't use that kind of cabling; it was a must for me and I've never tried playing console games on standard non-HDMI cables; I can imagine I wouldn't be pleased.
Sure, the game would almost definitely look better on my PC, and as I have a pretty nice setup on mine (used to game exclusively on my PC until a few years ago), when it drops in price I might even pick up an additional copy for my PC so I can see for myself. Until then, I'll keep enjoying my HDMI cables while playing and count myself lucky - the game is very beautiful.