Khettienna, that's what I was looking for 

  And ghastley, also good info.  This is definitely base form editing and not script based.  This is the situation I am faced with;
Oblivion...............
Mod A...............
Mod BVanilla Weapon
...........................NewWeapon A1
....................................................NewWeapon B1
as opposed to;
Oblivion...............
Mod A...............
Mod BVanilla Weapon....Vanilla Weapon.....Vanilla Weapon
...........................NewWeapon A1
....................................................NewWeapon B1
So the way I understand it, if a vanilla record is untouched, it remains the same.  But mod-added changes will be undone if a later mod doesn't include those changes or use a Bash Patch to import.