Have played all id Software games and loved them.
Rage is a good story with lots of potential. I can't understand why it is so huge in file size and so short in story length. When I got to the end I thought I was maybe a third of the way through using my gut sense from playing other games. So the end was a bit of a shock. This is the first game I've bought since Far Cry 2 which I have played at least 3 dozen times and still have not gotten bored with it. I can't criticize Rage too much. It has the Doom and Quake format as far as exploring the environment is concerned (mainly still a corridor game). Not sure where id is going now that the focus is on console sales for cash flow. I played Far Cry 2 on an XBox and found the anolog controls pretty lame. There is nothing that can compare to a keyboard and mouse in terms of reaction speed and accuracy.
I hope id Software (or whoever they are now) start developing games with the sandbox format as the main environment. Rage is sort of a move in that direction with the driving and random missions but the corridor parts are kind of old school.
Too bad they are seeing PC's as second fiddle now but that's life I guess. I hope the next installments improve things. Maybe make use of all those files installed for this first segment of the story...that would make more sense I think. 21 gigs is an awful lot of hard drive space to take up.
I enjoyed the story and liked playing what there was to play but expected something a bit more after all the years since the last Doom and Quake were released.