I tried restarting the game, and starting a new game, about half a dozen times. The same thing always happens. It does not matter whether it is Ralof or Hadvar who I go with. They both get stuck at exactly that same place. I have tried using the wiki to manually advance the quest, and can get the game to give me the prompt to search the barrel for potions. But that is as far as it will go. Ralof and Hadvar remain glued to the spot. It cannot be a mod conflict, because I disabled all the mods I had and tried it with a vanilla start, and still had this bug.
Has anyone else had this issue?
I found an old save from another character at the beginning of the game, and it works fine. I get to the storeroom and there are two Imperials in there who attack (following Ralof). Then Ralof prompts me to search for potions, and goes out the door with me. So I can still play the game normally. I just had to use the showracemenu command to change my character. But it would be nice to be able to start a brand new game sometime.