He just had to turn on me and try to warn the guards about my arrival on Kingsparrow Island. I proceeded to put a bolt in his head and let the fish eat him. I really liked him, too.

Anyone else do this?

I did the same thing on my high chaos playthrough. Actually, I reloaded to try and catch him with my sword once, but I ended up missing and having to blink/swim chase him down until he drove off the map, to which I reloaded again and did as you did.

On my first high chaos play through he didn't do it. Second time I knew I was aiming for the highest chaos and he did. Was so confused that I laughed in spite >.>

I had killed him before I even got off the boat. So I didn't even know that could happen.

While we are on the topic I was tired when I made this post so I'm just going to ramble;

On Low Chaos, Callista tells me that Samuel's been out on the river all the time, looking for me. And then....

http://imageshack.us/a/img560/35/dishonored2012101616180.jpg

Aww. Such a bro