Actually that doesn't say anything. http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/all?view=condensed&sort=desc you can see that Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 got 97.....legend of zelda 98, tony hawk 97...i know, their are different genders...but....le'ts face it, most of reviews today follow the hype of the moment.
So? The only game there that doesn't deserve that mark is Tony Hawk, and not for being a skating game, it's not that good anyways. But SM Galaxy 1 and 2 do, and Legend of Zelda probably too. I know what your point is, and I'm not trying to invalidate it, because most magazines are just pure garbage, they shouldn't be reviewing anything tbh, their lack of objectivity is immense, but your facts don't prove anything either.