Guilds are hollow now. There is no more series of earned promotions, you just go from apprentice to arch-mage, and that's it. They are all only a couple quests long.
This this this. Now don't get me wrong, I haven't yet beat the DB but if I'm on the last ques- which I think I am- then this guild is a joke. It's been fun, but remember OB when we got all these bonuses and weapons? I've had one bonus so far... WTH..
The MG was no a little better, consisting of about 4 or 5 quests but. Good story too IMO but so short...
The companions was well written, but very misleading... Still very short and can complete in around 2 hours.
The TG was awesome for me. It was well written and fun. It also lasted me awhile and I received some nice gear. The side jobs started to become redundant but they kept me busy.
I remember OB when I couldn't even complete 1 guild in a day! Sure, some weren't well written but they kept me busy. I just can't believe that they made the DB so short when OBs was so long.
Still, I love the guilds, just hate being able to beat two in one sitting.