I know Utherd the Unbroken has the possibility of bugs as a steward, but has anyone here have (or have had) her as a steward and had any problems?

I had her as a steward and I could not stand her.

Anytime you even get near her, she will challenge you to a fight,tell you you are weak and or how tough she is, and make other comments like "keep walking if you know whats good for you".This is all the same dialogue she has prior to becoming a steward and it's not that annoyting considering she sits by herself in the back of the Bannered Mare so you normally would not experience this add naseum.

Other than the dialogue (that was terrible and terribly annoying),I did not have any bugs with her at all.Very competent in a fight.

Thanks for the information! I started a new character, am at level 9, and not quite sure where I am taking this one. I beat her in a brawl and have her as a follower for now, but also just built the small house at Falkreath. I am just trying to get as much info as I can for a different steward than my normal options. For now, I am thinking this pc won't be a spellsword, so I want some muscle along with her for a while. lol I don't want to have to listen to that crap though.

Have her as a steward of Lakeview since Hearthfire came out for the PC. She has all the money I gave her to funish the place and has done very little of the sort. Not someone I will ever use as a steward again. Plus she spends most of her time outside away from the area bandits spawn and kill my damn cow and chicken. Worthless

Illia on the other hand. BEST STEWARD EVER imo. She fully furnished my dawnstar area home in several days minus the celler of course.

Sounds like I'll stick with Uthgerd just a bit longer until I have Rayya at Lakeview, and hope she doesn't glitch out on me. I will need a useful steward.