I am rping my character lived in an Orphanage for three years, which Grelod owned.
Because Grelod basicly screwed up a part of her childhood, I would love to kill her with that character. It makes sense, and I would help out the children too.

But she is good, would killing Grelod infront of the children be considered ''evil''?

The good thing to do would be to forgive her, killing a person is certainly 'evil' when it is ultimately just for your own vengeance.

The problem is she's a child abusing psycho so if you forgive her, she goes on to abuse more children.

Possibly killing them on occassion due to neglect.

Mace to the face time, people.

Would you kill her for the brotherhood ie for the money? or for revenge?

I wonder if you can kill her before taking on the DB quest to.

But to answer your question... I wouldn't say evil. more like revengeful and mercyful. If she's killing orphans and you kill her. Sounds like a good deed.

It would be a noble deed done in the wrong way. Since you can't send her off to jail, take a remaining option.

This is it. I never do the DB but my Skyrim world has no Grelod now. Go into the orphanage and Fus Ro Dah her. Then exit and check your stats. No murder. No bounty. I feel guilty but Grelod can't torture more kids.

No.