I bounce back and forth between BF3 and Skyrim during the day. I still love SWTOR and Eve Online, sadly I can't play them because my video card went into the crapper mode, and BF3 and Skyrim are on my PS3 so I have that at least.
I love SWTOR because of the story and I'm a Star Wars nerd/geek. I love everything about it except Jar Jar.. he needs to die, and the emo Anakin, even though it makes sense for the character, should have used a different actor. Also, not replacing the Original Anakin ghost. I love BF3 because I loved the first two, and they have typically been the more realistic combat experience (for a game) than anything on the market. It's a great game for fps enthusiasts.
Skyrim is a whole other beast. I loved Morrowind and Oblivion, the first two TES games I've ever gotten head deep into. I played Daggerfall on a friends computer long ago, and the small amount I played was pretty damn fun, I loved it but was never head deep into it because I didn't own it. Skyrim is very immersive, and despite my need for it to get even more so, it is very, very enjoyable. I almost prefer to play the TES games on console, but I miss mods for these games, because the modders (the good ones) typically make the game's experience so much more. I really miss that about playing them on my PC.
I do love Mass Effect, no matter what people say about it. I'm a Bioware fan, and I thoroughly enjoy just about everything they produce. I was glad when Bethesda put patch 1.4 out for the PS3, I really didn't want to boycott the company and sell all the games I have from them. I was 100% going to do it if they didn't fix a very bad issue on the PS3, but they did so I'm happy
