» Mon Jun 04, 2012 9:57 am
Yeah, I've already heard of others having the same problem, it's quite a buggy quest (like they all are). I was lucky enough to be able to beat up Belethor in Whiterun. Anyway, there's only one way to solve this, according to the UESP: "If you happen to kill one of the targets before you get the quest, you can no longer finish the quest or get farther along in the Guild. The only way to fix this is to type Setstage cr04 100 into the console". If you're playing on XBOX or 360, you're pretty much screwed. :/ You could try a reload from before the start of the quest, and hope he'll ask you to beat up someone else since it's a radiant quest.