Ive done all the quests (including the missing laser pistol unmarked quest) and kept McNamara as Elder and I gave Veronica a White Glove Society dress but Im still only liked. Ive been idolized by them only one time before and I think giving Veronica the dress is what did it but that only worked once out of fifty something times. So any one know if the reputation system with the BoS is bugged or could I be doing something wrong? No, I never gained any BoS infamy.