One of the reasons underclocking a GPU could or would work is IF your PSU is starting to fail this would lessen the load and allow you to play.
IF underclocking does help I would then look for the cause...either bad GPU and or failing PSU.
All Power supplys slowly lose there rated watts over time. this is a givin...
I experienced the "black screen" crashes in Oblivion. everyone told me it was my PS , I argued. I also said...but I can play such and such for hours....I was wrong.
My dumb ass had to learn the hard way.....I said..na its got to be the GPU...Bought a NEW GPU and guess what ...black screen crash with new gpu...sigh..bought a new PS and BOTH cards then worked...
YMMV