Well I went digging in the Vault to go look for some cool creature and here's what I found ( That would fit)
Mutant Cannibals (If the great divide is in fact the Grand Canyon)
Endless walkers ( seem like a really cool enemy, one of those once in a blue moon encounter ones)
Toads/ Frogs ( is there really some reason we don't have any of these? Did they go extinct?)
Spiders ( Yeah i know, some people have aracnaphobia, maybe implement an option to take them out?)
And uhm...yeah. About it for now.
Floaters ( They were originally supposed to be in the game so I don't see why not)
Catfish Mirelurks ( again, why not?)