I just got this one when I was telling Raul to leave so he can repair my stuff on the spot. then when i recruited him back i got the achievement. i know ive never recruited Lily Bowen, Rex, Rose of Sharon Cassidy, Arcade Gannon, but ive recruited Raul after the first time, 4 times. that would account for the four that i havent recruited yet. i dont know if someone already posted this, but has this happened to anyone else?

I've had this happen too. Can't remember how but the achievement popped up and I'd only recruited like two of the companions.

Hah this actually just happened to me. Im not complaining, but still. I told him to leave, then hit "Join me" instead of having him repair my inventory, and then had to fire him again, hit the same dialogue choice again, and finally got it right the third time. I then re-hired him, and the achievement popped up. I had only recruited Arcade, Boone, and Raul earlier, so the 4 times I re-recruited Raul I guess it counted as actual companions.

no complaints here either lol, i can spend more time on killing things. i was wondering if it has happened to anyone else, guess it has lol

Same thing happened to me. Still hadn't recruited Arcade but got the achievement.

Mybe you recruited them in other playthroughs so it counted does not say recruit all in one playthrough Raul could of been you last one.

That wasn't it, happened to me the first time around and had only fired and rehired Boone and EDE.

That wasn't it, happened to me the first time around and had only fired and rehired Boone and EDE.