The second was much worse. Because it removed the "mist" effect. So, in a certain point in the end game where this becomes significantly relevant to the story...The mist was not there. Needless to say, I was wondering what all the NPCs were talking about, and why I was using the weather-clearing shout..
I did figure it out of course, but it kinda ruined that part of the game, which was not a part of the game I think bethesda wanted ruined.
Of course i'm pretty sure they tried to make it impossible to re-maximize a window, but you can do so easily enough (Alt+tab out. Then click the minimized skyrim on the bottom toolbar, then hit the windows key, then click anywhere and it brings the game back up without shutting down.) Im guessing that part of the game was supposed to be a tad more interesting than what I saw.
