Nar, Powerfist just works as well.
Another thing i'd like to point out. The fact they gave us SO many unarmed choices that it's redonkulous!!!
So, me fighting a Casador/Deathclaw/Super Mutant Master with a frikkin pair of Boxing Gloves sounds SO much more convenient/aesthetic then fighting them with a BLADE?!
I honestly don't get it, Unarmed got SUCH a BIGGER and BETTER arsenal of variety then Melee did. I want to be a "New Vegas Samurai" but they simply WON'T let you! (And by just looking at the Achievement picture, where the hell is the GUITAR Melee Weapon?). OH let me guess it was "too powerful" and got cut? J. Christ man are you serious?!
WAYYYYYYYYY to make this game like a "TRUE RPG" there Obsidian!!! (LIES, all LIES!!!)
Oh, and whomever said Vance had a "special" Shiskehbab you're extremely WRONG. He had a special CHINESE OFFICER SWORD called Vampire's Edge. So get your facts str8 before sputtering BS please...
Here's an official list of swords from both F3 and NV:
Fallout 3:
Chinese Officer's Sword (Vampire's Edge and Jingwei's Shocksword)
Shiskebab
Samurai Sword
And excluding the Samurai Sword, that's a BASE of TWO SWORDS
Fallout: New Vegas
Bumper Sword
Machete (Machete Gladius and Liberator)(Even though I DO NOT count these as Swords IRL, to me they're just big KNIVES!)
Shiskebab (AND the fact you CANNOT CRAFT these at Workbenches hinders this Weapon all entirely IMHO!)
So they're even, for now. If the last add-on doesn't have a single sword then they can expect me NOT to buy this next one in June, AND the last in July. Period.
THAT, OR, they can bump the DMG of all mentioned above (Besides Shiskebab), to better fit "closer" to Oh Baby! Basically if you get that Melee weapon, you don't NEED another Melee weapon it's [censored]. They basically MAKE you use it because ALL OF THE OTHER MELEE WEAPONS completely svck compared to it.
I'm not saying "OMFG this game is terrible, it's a bad game, because it doesn't have enough swords". I like this game, and i'm TRYING to like it more and Swords were something I loved to hunt down in Fallout 3.
And as someone else mentioned, how the hell did THESE weapons get out here?:
Incinerator
Gauss Rifle
Tesla Cannon
And might I add these are all from BROKEN STEEL (besides the Gauss) one of the very LAST add-ons we got.
I understand you want us to use Guns more, but if you were going to HINDER basically every single Melee Weapon in the game to completely svck besides Oh Baby! Then what the HELL was the point of adding Melee/Unarmed into this game?! If they can't stop bullets, etc. etc. etc.?
Why are they in the game period if they don't want this game to be like Elder Scrolls? PLEASE tell me that?