I have used both Heavy Armor and Light Armor. And you have many good points here. But all of your objections to Heavy Armor can be answered. All in all, both styles of armor are viable. But in my opinion, if someone is going to be a warrior, heavy armor is clearly better choice. For stealth style and archers, I agree that light armor is a better fit.
ummm...i would say the opposite...anyone who wears Heavy Armor is just gimping themselves...lets look at this:
1. Light Armor becomes weightless at 50 skill....HA requires 70 skills AND HA requires you to take two useless perks to get weightless.
I do not take weightless perk in Heavy Armor. I just take 2 perks at the bottom to boost damage reduction. This gives comfortable protection in the beginning.
2. Light Armor DOES NOT need the Steed Stone freeing you up to use a different stone such as Warrior, Lady, Lord, or Atronach Stones.
Steed Stone is great for Heavy Armor. It's a great deal. It takes the place of 6 perks. Heavy Armor gets Heavier as you move to more advanced armor. In the early game, a heavy armor user can manage perfectly without Steed Stone. I personally take Lord Stone in the beginning for extra protection. If you stay with Wolf Armor, which is fairly light, Steed Stone is not such a great deal.
3. Light Armor looks way better then Heavy armor...its not even a contest...all the Cool armor sets are Light Armor IE: Dark Brother Hood, Theives Guild, Guild Master, Nightengale, etc.
This is personal preference. In my opinion, light armor does not look good at all on male characters. At the moment, my favorite armor is Steel Plate. I used to like Elven Armor and Glass Armor a lot, but my taste changed.
4. Glass Weapons are more then enough to beat the game...on level 50 i can kill anything quit easily with Glass Weapons...Ebony can be found easily, and Daedric Weapons are not even needed....everyhting in the game dies so easily anyways even Glass Weapons are overkill...so no need to even bother with the Heavy side of Smithing which frees those perks spots for other things.
I agree. I use Skyforge Steel Steel or Blades Sword and they are good enough for me. My primary bow is Elven Bow.
5. You can easily reach the Armor cap with Light Armor.
True, but it's easier with Heavy Armor. The main advantage of Heavy Armor is in the early game, I think. Light Armor gives you very little protection compared to Heavy Armor in the beginning, when every point of armor rating matters.
Early on HA has a better rarting then Light, but Light allows you to move faster, weighs less, can carry more, and you can sneak.....you cna take the Lord Stone to fill the gap AND get a 25% Magic Resist as icing on the cake....with HA you have to take 2 useless perks and reach 70 skill before it becomes weightless...or use the Steed Stone and give up The Lord Stone, Atronach (IMO are much more useful then the Steed)
Heavy Armor gives a lot better protection than Light Armor in the early game. Heavy Armor with Lord Stone gives a lot better protection than Light Armor with Lord Stone. I do not use the 2 perks in heavy armor and I do not worry about reaching 70 skill. Later on, I will often switch from Lord Stone to Steed Stone. By that time, I have largely solved the Magic Resistance problem through enchanting, Mara, and Alteration.
Light Armor has many advantages, I wore HA on my 3rd character just for RP....and i most likely will not go back to wearing it again...its just a waste and IMO outside of Iron, Steel, and Steel Plate HA just looks awful...Dwarven, Orchis, Ebony, and Dragon Plate Armor just look god awful......
This is personal preference. Some people like some things and other people like other things. I do not like the way Dragon Plate Armor looks either. I also do not like the way Dragon Scale Armor looks. I stay with Steel Plate Armor. It's fairly efficient perk-wise. You only need Steel, Elven and Advanced perks in smithing, and only 2 perks in the Heavy Armor tree to reach the armor cap. And you feel fairly safe from very beginning of the game and keeps pace with leveling enemies naturally.
On the Other hand, Fur/Hide/Studded, Elven, Scaled, Glass, and Dragon Scale Armor looks very nice in comparison, and the DB, Nightengale, and TG armors just add icing on the cake.....
Personally, I'm okay with Glass. I'm mostly okay with Scaled, except for the silly looking helmet. Dragon Scale Armor looks horrible in my opinion. DB outfit looks like a clown suit. Nightengale looks silly. TG armor is kinda okay, I guess.