the fact that skyrim allows you to play "as many characters as you want" is a necessity for this game, not, an advantage or something to boast about. roleplaying in an open-world rpg is basic gaming. all of these types of games MUST allow roleplaying. that's the major difference between, say, fallout3/morrowind/skyrim and mass effect.
the problem is that we, the players, must gimp ourselves to make the game difficult at the highest difficulty level designed by the developers. it should be the other way around.
I don't see it as gimping myself though. The cleric player I mentioned was something that I wanted to play. I don't purposefully ignore archery and sneak in order to be gimped, I do it because that character would be disdainful fo such cowardly things. I don't stick only to harvested materials for smithing in order to slow down the process of leveling it, I do it in order for it to feel like a more natural progression. It's a roleplaying thing. That character doesn't understand that buying all the iron ingots in town and making daggers would make her a more skillful smith- she has gathered some iron ore and animal pelts, and makes gear with them to sell. That's what makes sense to her.
It's just like me in real life. I'm a software developer. I don't write tons of easy code because that might increase my skill as a programmer. I write code as needed for my job, or sometimes as wanted for my personal enjoyment, and my skill progresses naturally. I'm trying to recreate that same thing in the game with character. That's the essence of roleplaying. You have to gimp yourself as a player, and consider what the character would know, and not what you would know.
The warrior on the other hand, is not really a roleplaying character, it's more of a "roll" playing character. In other words, it was deisgned to be a min-max type character. When I play that character, I'm not roleplaying, I'm playing hack-n-slash, grab all the loot, because sometimes that's fun.
By the way, I DO see it was a good thing that I can play multiple characters. I enjoy playing in multiple different styles. I don't see how that could be seen as anything BUT a plus. If you don't want to take advantage of that, there's nothing saying you have to make more than one character. It's NOT a neccessity. It's an option.


Ysgramor's Shield and Lord stone apparently suppress thier magic enough too. Oh well, might aswell get Spell Breaker and ignore enemies trough the rest of the game 
