Dark Brotherhood:
Pros:
- Easy money early on in the game.
- Enjoyable (if somewhat predictable) guild quest.
- 20000 Reward after completion of guild quest.
- Cool Armour.
- Access to advanced trainers (Alchemy and others I can't remember).
- Access to a follower if he survives and you can stand him.
Cons:
- Too much "Hail Sithis" religious crap. I'm a cold blooded killer not a priest.
- You have to get into a coffin with a many thousand year old corpse. I kid you not.
- Said corpse becomes your task giver after all is done. It's creepy.
- All the said trainers end up dead except the Alchemist at the end of the quest.
- Awfully boring side quests given by the dead lady. Go to location x. Speak with person so and so. Go to location y. Kill person so and so. No conditions, no prefered ways of killing them just kill them. Yawn.
Thieves Guild:
Pros:
- Plenty of Merchants and Fences at the end of the line which makes for easy money later on.
- Can eventually bribe guards to pay only half your fine and not lose any stolen goods.
- Guild quest can be tough at low levels. Fun but also (sadly) predictable.
- 4 Merchants inside your HQ eventually. Blacksmith, General, Alchemist and Mage.
- The coolest lloking armour in the game at the end of the guild quest. Especially for female characters. Personal opinion though.
- Advanced skill trainers (Archery, Sneak and Lock Picking if I remember correctly). They don't end up dead.
- Varying side quests that pays less that DB but is more fun to do. You even get to choose which you want to do.
Cons:
- Religion gets dragged into it too albeit to a much lesser extend.
- NPCS lack depth. Then again, I guess thieves are not deep people.
- You have to resort to common thuggery at points to progress. Luckily it stops after a certain point. So if you feel sorry for poor NPCS this one will get under your skin.
- Riften is almost as ugly as Windhelm. It's depressing to live here.
Of course if you just want the DB armour you can always kill Astrid instead of a hostage when she kidnaps you at which point you get tasked to wipe out the entire DB. Let the hunt begin.
