Anyone else having a problem with selecting a conversation response and the game using one of the others?

I make sure the one I want to say is highlighted, and in the center (selected?) position when I click on it, but VERY often the game decides I wanted to ask/say
something else - usually again, and again, and again. Even something as simple as donating to the beggar in Whiterun tries to make me give him the Argonian
Ale he wants (that I want to keep so I can track him down using the quest pointer).

Is there some way to select other than a mouse click, just in case this is a mouse related bug?

To answer your last question first: If the line is actually highlighted (whether or not in the center) you can use the enter or return key to activate. (NB: I have my "Use" key remapped to [Enter] so if you don't it might be the [E] key for you.

To answer your first question: I still have problems with this. Which line is actually highlighted may be difficult to discern. I have found that sometimes it takes a fraction of a second and may require scrolling the list for a line to actually become highlighted. Sometimes a line won't highlight until the NPC quits speaking.

All-in-all, this is a really clumsy interface.

It might be a case of mouse issues. Ive had a few games on PC (including Fallout 3) that had the mouse offset by a big margin. That is to say what I had the onscreen mouse hovered over was not what it clicked on. I dont recall how I solved it, other than it was either an incorrect graphics card setting or it was a conflicting program interfering with the mouse and the game.

It's not even that I'm clicking the topics out of order - when it bugs, it defaults to the top of the list (that I have usually tried already) rather than the one immediately above the one I select.

there's a bug on PC where the game sometimes loses the mouse pointer entirely, and will use the currently highlighted option regardless of where you click.

Feels like a bug introduced while porting from Xbox.

That sounds possible. Who do you think will fix the bug first, the modding community or developers?

What I find on the PC is that the dialog highlight will not move the 1st time my mouse moves to another selection. To get it to highlight the one I want to click I sweep my mouse up and down 2 or 3 times over the one I want and I will see it clearly highlight and I know it's now safe to click.

Consolitis disease has struck again

Patch 1.3 and this bug is still alive and well. Everyone else still got it too, or is it just me?