I'm similar. Sports games hold my attention, but I am only playing Skyrim in little 45 minute - 1 hour blocks. I need a fresh game...
Try some VNs. Some are more like books than games, but they are refreshing imo.
You can get Katawa shoujo and Narcissu for free. Narcissue is shorter, no interaction, but depressing.
KS has lots of text, but you still have choices that effect, what path your on. Some people get depressed, others feel happy.
Ok im going to stop trying to get more people into VNs now...
Dem feels.